 
|
Audio Asylum Thread Printer Get a view of an entire thread on one page |
For Sale Ads |
|
|
Audio Asylum Thread Printer Get a view of an entire thread on one page |
For Sale Ads |
216.196.142.10
In Reply to: Bummer? posted by Bambi B on February 9, 2005 at 11:18:45:
I agree. But how to document the actual history? Particularly the history of an instrument for which the origins are unclear. I agree that the events appear contrived. Well, it is fiction. I suspect that if the movie was simply little progidies playing to a meter machine, then to a conversvatory, then to a symphony, then to the old age home, then to the reading of the will, then to the grandchild, to begin over again, with the possible detour to a pawnshop, we would be saying the story has been told before, that it was boring, predictable, etc., which it would be. That history would probably be more realistic, and less contrived. Would you pay money to see it? I would not (well, I probably would as I try to see everything released, but I would be less happy). It would be less contrived, but would that make a better film? That the filmmakers attempted to be more ambitious, to show more drama, involve more cultures, is a good thing, and in the end, I think, makes for a better film. And Jackson, as always, gives a good performance.
Follow Ups:
jamesgarvin,Again, I agree. You're correct that many times stories about an instrument are as contricved as anything thrown at us in "The Red Violin". There is a harpsichord in a collection in Germany that for decades- perhaps 100 years was said to have bbe owned by JS Bach and because it had the rare 16' stop, everytone felt justified in putting in 16' stops. The same goes for the "Handel" harpsichord also eventually owned by George III. It's unlikely Bach every saw the former and Handel may have only played the latter once.
And also, you're right that movies generally need to heighten drama and conflict to be attractive. A famous screen writing coach- Syd Field said, "No one will ever go to see "The Village of the Happy, Sleeping People".
But, this subject -of a historic fiddle, would really happen in an academic/artistic world. This is not without drama as atist so often have trgic lives- Paganini's life would have made a much better fiddle movie I think. Look at the Hill Collection instruments. Those have provenences back to new or nearly new- a long time with an Amati, but none were forbidden contraband in Communinst China or traded to gypsies.
Yes, I suppose the movie makers had to hieghten the events, to sell tickets, I only wish it had been more skillful.
I'm perhaps overstating objections to "the Red Violin" as it does have entertaining and thought-provoking monements- it's the disjointedness that bothers me most.
Cheers,
Bambi B
Cheers,Bambi B
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Top of Page ]
[ Contact Us ]
[ Support/Wish List ]
[ Copyright © 2025, Audio Asylum, all rights reserved ]
