Re: Uh, Scott, guess reason is

Posted by Analog Scott (A) on March 20, 2005 at 15:08:01

In Reply to: Uh, Scott, guess reason is posted by tinear on March 20, 2005 at 14:02:55:

"alien to your powerful cortex.
Yes, the story occurred before the Holocaust but the film didn't. Get it?"

Yes, I get the fact that your views are so intensely anti-semitic that you think any depiction of any Jew struggling against prejudice in any place or any era is somehow about the holocaust. That's simply idiotic.

" It was chosen to make a point"

Bullshit, it was chosen because he was a part of that group of athletes that exceded theier expectations. Get a clue.

" (I have no doubt you fail to recognize propaganda when it hits you in the teeth so I'll help you)."

I have no doubt you see propaganda in any movie that depicts any Jew facing any sort of prejudice. That's your problem not mine.

"And...the movie sucked. Kind of an English Patient type of schmaltz-fest. Hey, you like feel good movies, be my guest."

Oh, movies about human triuph are catagorically schmaltzy. dude, really, get a clue.

"Scott, the 24-karat, guilt-dipped critic.
(And...have you told Virginia how to get in touch with me yet? Be sure to tell her I'm sure to be uglier than her current beau. Be useful, at least...)."

No, I see no reason to tell her to more anti-semitic pigs.

This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:

Follow Ups Full Thread

Topic - Chariots of Fire--- - patrickU 11:50:53 03/17/05 (19)

What ridiculous propaganda! Another portrayal - tinear 17:03:07 03/18/05 (14)

Re: Next, tinear attacks "Porkys"! - Gee LP 23:33:54 03/20/05 (1)

Re: Apologies to tinear - Gee LP 09:15:35 03/21/05 (0)

Re: My friend you may have a case of " idee fixe "------- - patrickU 05:04:15 03/19/05 (11)

I know, I know. You ignored the facts and - tinear 08:55:55 03/19/05 (10)

Re: I know, I know. You ignored the facts and - patrickU 09:38:50 03/19/05 (0)

Re: I know, I know. You ignored the facts and - Analog Scott 09:19:43 03/19/05 (8)

Re: I know, I know. You ignored the facts and - patrickU 09:44:12 03/19/05 (7)

Oh, so a post about race necessarily - tinear 04:15:46 03/20/05 (6)

Re: Oh, so a post about race necessarily - Analog Scott 09:30:24 03/20/05 (2)

Uh, Scott, guess reason is - tinear 14:02:55 03/20/05 (1)

Re: Uh, Scott, guess reason is - Analog Scott 15:08:01 03/20/05 (0)

Re: Well Tin " Chariots of Fire " is also about... - patrickU 06:28:39 03/20/05 (2)

No, Patrick, no bias: I just don't like to be - tinear 14:06:22 03/20/05 (1)

Re: We have left the shores... - patrickU 01:28:46 03/21/05 (0)

One of my favorites too, Patrick - padreken 14:24:14 03/17/05 (3)

Re: One of my favorites too, Patrick - patrickU 07:35:32 03/18/05 (2)

You are right, Patrick - padreken 08:34:15 03/18/05 (1)

Re: Thank you for the link, Padre.... - patrickU 08:59:38 03/18/05 (0)

Follow Ups

Re: Uh, Scott, guess reason is - Analog Scott 15:08:01 03/20/05 (0)

You can not post to an archived thread.