Films/DVD Asylum

Try metacritic.com...

207.67.53.106

In Reply to: RE: Any legit alternatives? posted by Kenreau on September 09, 2008 at 09:47:03

...which weights the reviews.

Rotten Tomatoes is not as reliaboe IMO, although it has legit reviewers, it has a whole lot more wannabes with websites and little actual insight. Even some of the pros on RT are more consumer guide types who really aren't very good at anything in depth.

There is virtually nothing on TV that I would ever trust for movie reviews now. It's "read" or be at extreme risk.

Personally, I have a few reviewers/film writers whom I follow fairly closely and whose opinions I respect.

Follow Ups:

RE: Try metacritic.com... oh yeah - Kenreau 21:31:52 09/09/08 (0)
Excellent recommendation. I forgot about metacritic. I had skimmed it before for music reviews and forgot about the movie and game reviews.

Thanks
Harmonia - PhilJ 18:25:51 09/09/08 (2)
what are the critics that you follow closely?

fwiw I like Time Out New York magazine. In general I agree with the reviewers and they are not afraid to slam a popular film or rave about a quirky effort - just my type of folk!

also: I avoid Leonard Maltin or Peter Travers, the closest thing to shills the industry has IMO

thanks

Phil
- A varied group. - Harmonia 13:52:22 09/11/08 (1)
  I sometimes look to diferent critics for different types of films.
  I nearly always check out Stephanie Zacharek at salon.com (and Andrew O'Hehir at same spot for indies and foreign). Steph and I are frequently on the same wavelength, and her reviews are lengthy and in depth. Even if I ultimately disagree, I understand her POV and can adjust from there.
  Kenneth Turran at LA Times - there's another (female) critic on this daily (whose name escapes me) who's done some nice work too.
  Ty Burr - Boston Globe
  Michael Wilmington - used to be at the Chicago Trib but is elswhere now.
  David Kehr when I can find him.
  MaryAnn Johansen at FlickFilosopher.com is great for all things geek.
  I like to read Dan Jardine's thoughts on film, current or classic.
  Will also look at David Denby at New Yorker. And sometimes the folks at the NY Times. David Eddelstein occassionally.
  Peter Travers was once actually a good critic, not that you could tell nowdays. When RS actually gave him space and motivation, he had some cogent things to say about contemporary cinema. That was over ten years ago. Travers is smart enough to know better but he's now marginal interst at best.
  Ebert is an excellent writer, but he's way too forgiving of commercial pablum. But he can be quite good on individual films and classics. He is absolutely sincere in his passion for movies.
  If I'm going to see a movie no matter what, I try not to read any reviews. I hate spoilers and prefer to watch new films with a "clean" eye.
  There are more good film writers about, but I don't put much stock in the mass media outlets like EW, USA Today et al. People like Rex Reed and Leonard Maltin is completely off my radar. I NEVER watch "happy face" local or national movie moments on Today or suchlike. Too "consumer guide" for me.
  I loathe the concept of giving a film a letter grade, just hate it completely. I'd often rather see and interesting failure than a mediocre success. So I avoid sites with this kind of structure.
  
  Edits: 09/11/08
  - thanks for such a response - PhilJ 18:09:57 09/13/08 (0)
    and resource for reviews! Salon is a nice site. I agree exactly about Ebert, he is such a good writer that I read him anyway even if he is too easy on the marginal films out there. I will look for the others...
    
    thanks
    
    Phil

Post a Followup:

FAQ

Post a Message!

Forgot Password?

Moniker (Username):
Password (Optional):
	Remember my Moniker & Password (What's this?) Eat Me
E-Mail (Optional):
Subject:

Message:	(Posts are subject to Content Rules)

Optional Link URL:
Optional Link Title:
Optional Image URL:
Upload Image:
E-mail Replies:	Automagically notify you when someone responds.

To view your new posting or follow-up, click on the RELOAD or REFRESH button on your browser.

This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:

Parts Connexion