 
|
Audio Asylum Thread Printer Get a view of an entire thread on one page |
For Sale Ads |
|
|
Audio Asylum Thread Printer Get a view of an entire thread on one page |
For Sale Ads |
In Reply to: Re: shame on you posted by chrisc on May 29, 2002 at 09:14:44:
nt
Follow Ups:
Yes I could, but there are plenty of critics who are paid to do that sort of thing and I think pretty much all of them can elaborate.
are unwilling to support that condemnation with facts, opinion, reasoned argument etc.
and blithely pass off the responsiblity of doing so to other "critics" who get paid to do so. Sounds
disingenuous and downright intellectually dishonest to me. Either
put up or shut from now on! - AH P.S.- No one on this site gets
paid to review as far as I know, are you implying that you should?
If you failed to draw the same conclusions as I, upon watching this shoddy tripe, I don't see how I can help you.You have lived this long, all the while making observations and reconciling these observations with your set of beliefs and values. I don't believe anything I write will change you or your opinion of the movie nor should it. However....
In the interest of defending myself against the somewhat justifiable criticism of being a sort of hit and run poster I offer the following (I wrote by myself, with no help from a critic!!!!!!!!!):
Here is a movie targeted to a certain type of woman. It manages to be offensive, not only to that subgroup, but to women in general. The movie is totally lacking in any sort of artistic merit, and exists as a sort of marketing experiment gone very wrong. This pathetic cookie-cutter of a movie is never less than predictable and never more than the bare minimum (and sometimes not even that). Stereotypes abound and
nobody is spared the dull tip of the writers' pens. This would all be ok if any of the jokes worked. They don't. There's just no humanity to be found in this utterly calculated piece of horseshit.There you go.
You stated:## Here is a movie targeted to a certain type of woman. It manages
to be offensive, not only to that subgroup, but to women in
general ##What type of woman??? How do you know women were offended? Do
you have access to polls?You stated:
## The movie is totally lacking in any sort of artistic merit... ##
Some of course, would disagree with this type of absolutist statement,
especially in the area of actor performance.You stated:
## This would be OK if any of the jokes worked. They donīt. ##
Found myself chuckling throughout. Of course, humor is a subjective
matter, sometimes I laugh at things others donīt, sometimes vice
versa, and then sometimes we laugh together! Bwwwaaaaaaa!You stated:
## Thereīs just no humanity to be found... ##
īPlease donīt tell Mel and Helen there was no warmth whatsoever
in their ending kiss, might hurt their feelings to insinuate they
were merely mannequins mechanically going through the motions.P.S. - I consider WWW harmless enough, it is mean-spiritied, propaganda
films like ĻThelma and LouiseĻ, that disturb me.
nt
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Top of Page ]
[ Contact Us ]
[ Support/Wish List ]
[ Copyright © 2024, Audio Asylum, all rights reserved ]
