 
|
Audio Asylum Thread Printer Get a view of an entire thread on one page |
For Sale Ads |
|
|
Audio Asylum Thread Printer Get a view of an entire thread on one page |
For Sale Ads |
71.92.69.31
In Reply to: The Devil Wears Prada posted by dave c on September 23, 2006 at 14:15:37:
my wife works in the high-end retail fashion biz and I have worked in that world as well...I thought Streep was luminous as the Miranda Priestly character who I'm sure was patterned after Grace Mirabella (former Vogue fashion editor) and editor of Mirabella magazine. I also agree that Stanley Tucci's bitchy fashion maven character was good...but he has played a version of this character before...most notably in Shall We Dance. The dialogue was certainly representative of individuals surrounding the world of haute couture... especially the insecurity and transciency of the business. IMO Streep really should be nominated for a supporting actress nomination for this film. I thought the fashion for the Anne Hathaway character was spot-on...although a little too much Chanel influence for my taste...but again it was about fashion and fashion IS about personal taste...and while there are parameters...it is personal....
Follow Ups:
friend who happens to be a first cousin who worked for several major fashion mags (including Vogue) as a photog years ago.
As with most satires and comedy, occasionally it's a bit over the top but the fashion industry has much more than its share of people that ARE over it.
Streep, Tucci, that English girl Friday, and Hathaway all were good. The two male romantic leads entirely were forgettable.
The Hathaway character was exactly the same character as the 40s secretary who after an after work drink with the boss would loosen her hair only for him to say "But Miss Jones, you're... beautiful".
Her boyfriend was upset that she worked late, but he was some sort of chef and was presumably working till, say, midnight most nights.
Her best friend who got so upset the writer kissed her on the cheek at the gallery opening would certainly not be surprised by the universal greeting amongst the glitterati.
The idea of her quitting when she realised she had lost her soul (something like that) was just too cliched for words.
I thought this as just another piece of frippery like Pretty Woman.
Vacuous.
And yes I have also hung around the fashion world and yes the sycophancy is just like that and I am sure you are right as to the model for the Streep character.
Still pretty disappointing, right down to the camera shots... right at the end where Hathaway sees Streep across the road and walks away after that exchange of looks, well 20 seconds later the car is still going past her.
Sorry, in my opinion it was sloppy and would have been better edited down to an hour Tv show.
had a hackneyed "plot:" most films do.
Yes, at this point in film history we've seen just about all characters (except for art house films which have their own group of stock characters).
What distinguishes efforts, therefore, is the quality of the dialogue, acting good enough for us to become involved in the story and care about the characters, and direction smooth enough for the film effortlessly to move along.
You didn't enjoy the acting, you originally posted, so for you, it couldn't "work."
I enjoyed the acting of all the females and Tucci, so for me, it was worthwhile.
The center of the film had to be good and I thought Hathaway was excellent.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Top of Page ]
[ Contact Us ]
[ Support/Wish List ]
[ Copyright © 2024, Audio Asylum, all rights reserved ]
