Films/DVD Asylum

Re: Sideways: ( Warning spoilers)

198.81.26.40

[ Follow Ups ] [ Post Followup ] [ Thread: Display All Email ] [ Films/DVD Asylum ]

Analog Scott

(A)

In Reply to: Sideways: posted by tinear on February 2, 2005 at 13:14:05:

Dude what movie did you watch? The one I saw was nothing like your description. You only saw one note when Paul Giamatti was facing his x wife and her new husband and found out she was expecting? You saw just another asshole when wrecked his car to cover for his best friend? You saw just an asshole with one note every time he squirmed with discomfort over his friend lying about his novel being published? You saw one note when he was dealing with his feelings of failure as a writer? You saw a one note asshole when he laughed his ass off at his friend when he showed up naked at the door or when he went in and got his friends wedding ring back? You saw a one note asshole when he was grappling between his feelings for Mia and his unrequited love for his x? I saw something quite different than you did.

Follow Ups:

Scott, you are describing his actions. I am - tinear 17:37:33 02/02/05 (3)
describing the ACTING.
- Re: Scott, you are describing his actions. I am - Analog Scott 08:18:44 02/05/05 (0)
  No, I am citing examples and discussing his choices as an actor. That is acting, making choices and executing those choices. The examples I cited IMO demonstrate the range and depth of his acting that you say wasn't there.
- The acting - sjb 17:50:37 02/02/05 (1)
  in that moment when she said she was pregnant, was brilliant.
  Question...
  You said there are 4 excellent performances yet you bag on one of them...which is it?
  
  "Where are we going? And what am I doing in this hand basket?"
  - Re: The acting - Bulkington 09:38:07 02/03/05 (0)
    Agreed. His performance was brilliant from beginning to end.

This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:

Sonic Craft

You can not post to an archived thread.