 
|
Audio Asylum Thread Printer Get a view of an entire thread on one page |
For Sale Ads |
|
|
Audio Asylum Thread Printer Get a view of an entire thread on one page |
For Sale Ads |
104.185.157.178
In Reply to: RE: A question for you posted by Victor Khomenko on October 21, 2020 at 05:48:10
Keep in mind, it's been 2(?) years since I saw it. First, I saw people, not nationalities, so my being born and raised American, had no bearing on how I received this movie. The themes were universal. The fight for survival on the front lines. The perceived ignorance up the chain of command. The loss felt at home. I'd posit, that any person, regardless of nationality, not moved by the mother's visit to the hospital and then the gravesite, must have the heart of stone. Altho it's Russian and, yea, there were some things I may not have gotten, there were some things I learned as well about the cohesion in the platoon, i.e., that Russian soldiers weren't just faceless masks in the horde of manpower that Russian had to draw upon. They, at least as shown in the series, cared about each other as troops of other nations did. And yes, I did notice the funny cigarettes that still appeared in the 1980s movie, 9th Company.
----------------------
"E Burres Stigano?"
Follow Ups:
The film is producing avalanche of emotions - its director Sergei Ursuliak is a good master, and here he shines.
The very battle was completely unnecessary - just two bloody murderers killing the untold number of innocent participants for the sake of their egos must count as one of the most disgusting episodes in that horrible war.
I also found it rather unfortunate that this epic work has received... four... that is correct - four... reviews on imdb. That tells you something about the average... and not so average... viewer. Makes you feel those hundreds of thousands truly died in vain.
Such events are rare... but it made me wonder if I hate the soviets enough.
and yes, that's correct. Quite surprising considering what an epic production this was. I'm going to catch this again if for no other reason than to refresh my memory, vis a vis, the battle scenes. My recollection was they reeked of authenticity, similar to those in the opening scenes of City Of Life And Death (thank you Tinear for the reco). I also recall reading that the movie diverged from the book towards the end quite a bit. That surely must have been a choice made by the producers when weighing the resources they had to tell the story. I found the ending lacking and short but the journey to get there more than made up for this. BTW, that's my only real criticism of the series. Glad you're enjoying this the second time around.
----------------------
"E Burres Stigano?"
I can't wait for another night... I wait till my wife retires, and spend 40-50 minutes with it... it was more last night, I just didn't have strength to stop it - mother visiting the hospital episode.
Thank you again for mentioning it. I am going to download the book, it's been long time.
BTW, perhaps a good companion book would be "In the Trenches of Stalingrad" by Viktor Nekrasov, take a look if you have not read it.
but I can't honestly say my eyes were dry either throughout that hospital/graveyard episode. Very, very, powerful scenes.
----------------------
"E Burres Stigano?"
Edits: 10/22/20
Since I finished watching the film, I can't stop thinking about it and its characters and situations. I also read some critical articles on it, which I invite anyone interested to do also.
Just a couple of points here... one - Grossman draws direct parallel between nazism and communism. Among the Russians whom I know, this is the subject of endless discussion. I, for one, totally agree with Grossman, that the two systems were basically the result of the same ideology.
The other interesting point concerns the result of the battle - instead of the frequently presented beginning of liberation, to Grossman (I agree with him here too) it was the conclusion of total enslaving of the soviet people.
After the battle power of Stalin and his henchmen, their grip on the population, have reached their pinnacle.
The film leaves out some significant chapters, those dealaing with the German concentration camps. These are also incredibly important, but perhaps were edited due to the overall size of the work.
The victory resulting in total enslavement of the Soviet people makes perfect sense. I had never thought of it like that. Agree that the left out content was a decision based on available resources to the film makers.
Grossman's story, in regard to the writing of the book, and its eventual publication after his death, would make one Helluva movie.
----------------------
"E Burres Stigano?"
| FAQ |
Post a Message! |
Forgot Password? |
|
||||||||||||||
|
||||||||||||||
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Top of Page ]
[ Contact Us ]
[ Support/Wish List ]
[ Copyright © 2025, Audio Asylum, all rights reserved ]