Films/DVD Asylum

Masterpiece is too big a word, it presumes too many things

71.203.125.32

Victor Khomenko

M

In Reply to: RE: Is "Dr. Strangelove" Kubrick's masterpiece?? posted by Mike K on August 22, 2009 at 13:50:44

One of them is sense of proportion and knowing where to stop. Kubrick lost there on these counts. The out of control arm scene is so ridiculously primitive, it is capable of single handedly destroying any claim at greatness. Masters just don't make such mistakes. Throughout his career Kubrick remained the master of scenes, but not of films. His early works might be the exception to that rule.

Follow Ups:

A satire -- as "Dr. Strangelove" is -- is the artistic equivalent of "reductio ad absurdum" in Logic... - orejones 03:56:03 08/29/09 (1)
...and it works best by exaggerating characters and situations up to a point close to distortion, what makes them even more recognisable...

Or maybe it bites too close to your bone? Your cybermisbehaviour, and the character you portray of yourself, certainly wouldn�t be misplaced if in this film...

Kubrick was a true master, and "Dr. Strangelove" is one of his masterpieces, much better than "Barry Lyndon" indeed. And it will still be alive and fresh as long as there are patrioteer kooks thumbing their hollow chests around...

BF
- RE: OH Boy! Yes it is a satire and you are the satyr of politic. - patrickU 06:03:15 08/30/09 (0)
  It suffice for you that your political vision is realized for placing Stangelove and counting it to the first rang of goodness in the film Olympia.
  Now I just saw it again after many years, and it has lost the power, partly lost, it once had.
  It belong to the Vietnam and the anti war movement, it stick too much in this " Zeitgeist " to be the film you pretend it to be.
  Now it is, like Victor said, one with good scenes, as most of SK films are.
  A much lesser work than Barry Lindon for sure.
  
  And I don�t know why you attack Victor on personal matter when it goes to a film.
  Every one is entitle to his own view.
  And mine is that Kubrick is way too much overestimate, and I had for years the highest meaning for his films.
  Not anymore, of course he is one of the greatest.
Shakespeare had to throw a few lines to the cheap seats - late 05:58:36 08/27/09 (5)
Strangelove is a classic. Half a century old and it still grabs people with it's vitality and it's long dark look into madness.
Think as you wish, no ever brings up your favorite Kubrick. I can't even remember the name. He won't be remembered for it, or 2001, or any of the others.
Strangelove has become part of the culture, not just a movie, an iconic shorthand to
describe something inside us that defies easy explanation.

Edits: 08/27/09 08/27/09
- In fifty years no one will know what the film is about - Victor Khomenko 06:32:42 08/27/09 (4)
  That is problem with such works, as opposed to more timeless ones.
  
  Call it a classic or whatever you wish, it will join the ranks of works of art perhaps unjustly forgotten. Some great masterpieces, like 12 Chairs... taken out of their historical context become deflated balloons.
  
  The Paths of Glory, on the other hand, will stay with us, because it transcends the particular piece of history, and speaks a much more universal, HUMAN language.
  - It's already 45 years old * - Mike K 09:36:52 08/27/09 (3)
    - late is about twice as old nt - Victor Khomenko 09:44:55 08/27/09 (2)
      .
      - I am sure we will all forget about it in 5 years time... nt - late 05:51:11 08/30/09 (1)
        
        In Reply to: RE: late is about twice as old nt posted by Victor Khomenko on August 27, 2009 at 09:44:55
        
        .
        
        That's fifty years from now, buddy - Victor Khomenko 06:25:09 08/30/09 (0)
        
        In Reply to: RE: I am sure we will all forget about it in 5 years time... nt posted by late on August 30, 2009 at 05:51:11
        
        Wasn't too hard to figure out.

Post a Followup:

FAQ

Post a Message!

Forgot Password?

Moniker (Username):
Password (Optional):
	Remember my Moniker & Password (What's this?) Eat Me
E-Mail (Optional):
Subject:

Message:	(Posts are subject to Content Rules)

Optional Link URL:
Optional Link Title:
Optional Image URL:
Upload Image:
E-mail Replies:	Automagically notify you when someone responds.

To view your new posting or follow-up, click on the RELOAD or REFRESH button on your browser.

This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:

Sonic Craft