Audio Asylum Thread Printer

Get a view of an entire thread on one page

FAQ / News / Events

Films/DVD Asylum

I'm glad you didn't like it. The director, Kim Reichardt, isn't an easy one. Like

67.160.130.12

In Reply to: RE: 'Meek's Cutoff' is the strangest movie I've seen in decades posted by jeffreybehr on May 29, 2011 at 11:51:59

an extremely rich food you've never sampled before, her art takes some familiarity, patience, and understanding. On the trail, it wasn't "John Wayne vs Indians" at every turn. I thought Michelle Williams gave a powerful, understated performance, perfectly portraying a quietly courageous and independent woman. The tension between the Indian and Meek I thought was riveting, as was the females' reactions to it. The film was shot in a singular fashion, especially for Westerns set upon the wide open prairie: the framing was very closed, adding tension and impending doom to the slow progress of the tiny caravan. This film is as unlike the typical Western as a romantic period symphony is from a baroque chamber work: you have to be aware of the smallest "notes." The ensemble acting is nuanced and very fine.
Reichardt's previous efforts, similarly, are quiet affairs that detonate after the fact. "On Joy," a highly recommended film about two young men that have been friends but haven't seen one another for some time and decide to spend some time together at a remote Oregon hot springs deep in the forest is a gem.
Anyhow, Reichardt isn't going to become a household name nor win an Academy Award for direction anytime soon. Like Bresson, she has an inimitable style and one that yields great rewards to those that "get it."

Follow Ups:

...I finally saw the film......... - RedGrant 22:00:18 06/02/11 (0)
...and even though I don't consider, this to be a 'masterpiece' yet, bout I did like the movie, and the ending was totally appropriate. In fact, I am glad the director didn't put on that typical 'hollywood' ending on this one.

Btw. I thought '2001' was a bore, too when I was a teenager. I was big on 'Star Wars' back then.

Now, I try to catch '2001' whenever shown on theater.
You're glad I didn't like it? Wow is THAT snobbish... - jeffreybehr 18:18:47 05/29/11 (5)
..as if mere literate, thoughtful movie lovers enjoy this movie, it isn't weird enough.
----------
Tin-eared audiofool, former fotografer, and terrible competitive-pistol shootist.
"Everything that can be counted does not necessarily count; everything that counts cannot necessarily be counted." Albert Einstein.
- Not snobbish; it's a comment on your earlier ones. You complain the pace is slow. That betrays - tinear 22:22:16 05/29/11 (3)
  an inability to realize that is the point! Walking alongside and riding inside a wagon WAS slow. It was a brutal, boring slog. And it was dangerous. The countryside also wasn't Northern California: it was monotonous scrub-brush country where a tree indeed was an unusual sight. Complaining that a film showed an authentic, true-to-life situation is a rather shallow criticism, isn't it?
  As far as the characters: did you expect biographies? Their actions and well-chosen words told you all you needed to know.
  Anyhow, as I said, that's the director's style. I find it far more interesting than Malick, another minimalist American director. I wonder if you'd like the film better the second time around? Probably not. Myself, I found Michelle's performance confirms my view of her as one of the absolute best actresses now working. BTW, this film is based on a true story, though the wagon train was far larger.
  - RE: Not snobbish; it's a comment on your earlier ones. You complain the pace is slow. That betrays - RedGrant 15:31:56 05/30/11 (2)
    "As far as the characters: did you expect biographies? Their actions and well-chosen words told you all you needed to know.
    Anyhow, as I said, that's the director's style. I find it far more interesting than Malick, another minimalist American director. I wonder if you'd like the film better the second time around? Probably not. Myself, I found Michelle's performance confirms my view of her as one of the absolute best actresses now working. BTW, this film is based on a true story, though the wagon train was far larger. "
    
    Is it something along the line of Kubrick? I didn't like '2001' at first, but as I get older, the more I appreciate '2001'.
    
    Btw. I outgrew 'Star Wars' a long time ago.
    - No. Nothing like Kubrick's visual fireworks. It is paced like many slow movements of sonatas or symphonies, - tinear 16:42:09 05/30/11 (1)
      I suppose some would just skip over those because they're "too slow....."
      - Some want to get to A from B.......... - RedGrant 20:22:38 05/31/11 (0)
        
        In Reply to: RE: No. Nothing like Kubrick's visual fireworks. It is paced like many slow movements of sonatas or symphonies, posted by tinear on May 30, 2011 at 16:42:09
        
        ...and that's all that matters. For some others, it's the journey itself.
        
        I've always been more interested in the journey, not the destination.
- "Wow is THAT snobbish..". Yup, one of the snootiest things he's said in awhile - Road Warrior 18:43:00 05/29/11 (0)
  and THAT'S saying something.
  
  Thank you for your review. At best I'll catch this on HBO in a few months. Looking at its 6 week gross, I'm surprised it didn't go direct to dvd.
  
  "I'd like to own a squadron of tanks"

Post a Followup:

FAQ

Post a Message!

Forgot Password?

Moniker (Username):
Password (Optional):
	Remember my Moniker & Password (What's this?) Eat Me
E-Mail (Optional):
Subject:

Message:	(Posts are subject to Content Rules)

Optional Link URL:
Optional Link Title:
Optional Image URL:
Upload Image:
E-mail Replies:	Automagically notify you when someone responds.

To view your new posting or follow-up, click on the RELOAD or REFRESH button on your browser.

This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:

Atma-Sphere Music Systems, Inc.