 
|
Audio Asylum Thread Printer Get a view of an entire thread on one page |
For Sale Ads |
|
|
Audio Asylum Thread Printer Get a view of an entire thread on one page |
For Sale Ads |
121.222.34.160
In Reply to: RE: I've been wanting to post about 7.1 posted by cfraser on March 13, 2009 at 10:24:11
I just checked my collection and found 4: Prince Caspian, The Golden Compass, Hellboy II, and Pan's Labyrinth. Interesting that 2 of them are basically children's pictures and the other 2 are directed by Guillermo Del Toro. Perhaps there are some trends apparent there.
Surprisingly, I found a DTS HDMA 6.1 soundtrack, something I didn't think existed: X-Men III The Last Stand. It had a DTS ES 6.1 soundtrack o n DVD so obviously they just remastered that soundtrack. Shows I was wrong when I said there were no high def 6.1 tracks.
David Aiken
Follow Ups:
Stargate is 6.1 DTS-HD High Resolution Audio and Top Gun is 6.1 DTS-HD Master Audio. There are a few more, but I can't remember which ones right now.
I have T2 on LD, T2: Special Edition -- Judgement Day on LD, T2: Ultimate Edition on DVD, T2: Extreme Edition on DVD and T2: Judgement Day on Blu-ray. For the betting crowd, what are the odds that I'll have the new Blu-ray version, T2: Skynet Edition , when it comes out?
I've got Stargate. The packaging says DTS HDMA 5.1 and I just played the opening and checked. It comes up as 5.1 on my info display.
BUT I'm in Australia and the packaging also says I have a zone B release. I also don't have the words "Extended Cut" on the front cover of the packaging and there's an Australian PG rating label over the area of the front picture where the figures appear below the pyramid to the left and there's a couple of other differences to the packaging so we got a different print run for the cover. Though the cover doesn't say "Extended Cut" I had the DVD with the extended cut and the length and contend of the BD seems identical, at least from memory. The timing of my BD copy matches the timing of the US BD release according to Amazon's info but Amazon doesn't say how many channels the soundtrack is.
I checked 2 US reviews. One says "English Dolby Digital Surround EX/English DTS-HD High Resolution" and doesn't state the number of channels for the DTS HD track. The other says "English: Dolby Digital 5.1 EX/English: DTS-HD 5.1". My packaging states "English DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1; English Dolby Digital 5.1".
It may actually be a zone free disc with packaging for release here, or it may be a different release to what you get in the US, but since it was released here after the US I would expect it to be the same material including soundtrack and from the reviews I could quickly find I can see nothing that indicates a 6.1 HD track for the US issue.
You may have a 5.1 Dolby Digital EX track but that's not a high def soundtrack. You may be picking up on that because my copy defaults to the Dolby low def soundtrack unless I manually select the DTS HD MA track. I've got my PS3 set to PCM output so of course the display for the track shows 5.1 (EX is matrixed, not discrete) and it's 5.1 channels that gets passed to my receiver.
Interesting. I can't say you're wrong about your release of Stargate having a high def 6.1 track but mine doesn't and it's hard to imagine Universal preparing separate 5.1 and 6.1 high def tracks for release in different zones.
The above may be a lot of words to waste on whether or not this disc is 6.1 but it's of interest to me as to just how much the local releases here vary from the US release.
David Aiken
The back of the case says DTS HD High Resolution ES Audio (the ES refers to an extra channel) and the PS3 says DTS-HD HR 6.1 channel when I ask for disc information. The UPC is 0 12236 19155 1 80 and it's from Lionsgate (the second pressing, as the first had some subtitle issues), if that makes any difference.
Since you have a PS3, as long as you have the latest firmware, you have decoding of DTS-HD Master Audio and DTS-HD High Resolution Audio. If your copy of Stargate says DTS-HD MA on the PS3, then it's a different encoding than the US version -- ours is DTS-HD HR at 3Mb/s CBR.
The back of my case says DTS HD Master Audio 5.1, my PS3 confirms that, mine has a different bar code number, and the packaging says Universal and Studio Canal with no mention of Lionsgate.
Obviously different releases.
Interesting. I'd rather have HD MA than HD HR, but I'd also prefer 6.1 to 5.1. On balance I'll go for the HD MA. I'd rather have lossless sound with fewer channels but I'd also rather have a disc that I know I can play and it sounds like I probably wouldn't be able to play the US release.
David Aiken
Is it common in Australia you can't play U.S. BDs? From what I've read, relatively few European BDs can't be played in the U.S., so far. Unlike with DVDs, on "regular" players. I don't have any non-U.S./Canada BDs yet.
Agree with you on the lossless vs the multi-channel lossy though, and in fact I refuse to buy any BDs without lossless (I'm pointing at YOU, Warner Brothers, who have lossless on less than 50% of your BD releases...but then you never did care about sound quality).
The data on the stats site in Joe's response to me indicates that 69.35% of the BD releases listed are region free. Assuming that list is a pretty complete list of US releases, then roughly 70% of US releases are playable on BD players sold in Australia and 30% aren't.
The situation is different with DVDs. There was a federal court case here years ago which resulted in a ruling that region free players did not breach copyright laws. If an Australian resident legally acquires a disc, paying copyright charges in the process, they are legally entitled to be able to play it and if that requires a region free player the resident has the right to have a region free player. As a result, nearly every DVD player sold in Australia has automatically been region free for some years.
Now with the introduction of BD, we're back to zoned players. I haven't come across a region free BD player. The situation isn't as bad with BD because more stuff is region free than ever was the case with DVDs, but I'm not aware of any BD players that are region free when it comes to playing DVDs. That means I've had to keep my old DVD player in order to play my few Region 1 DVDs.
I've bought a few BDs from the US but the problem is often getting reliable info on whether or not the disc is region free. Amazon sometimes reports region free discs as Zone A so you have to take a risk based on what the reviews have said. One of the discs I've got from Amazon is region free and plays fine but it states it's Zone A on the packaging so I can't really fault Amazon too much. The review was right and they weren't.
What's interesting is what is region free and what isn't. It varies depending on the film with some labels but some other labels seem to go entirely one way or the other. There doesn't seem to be a consistent rule followed by everyone. It depends on the label and I've seen that I can't rely on the label's packaging to tell me whether the disc is region free or what kind of a soundtrack it really has. That's even more frustrating in many ways than having to deal with the zone system and the fact that sometimes material I want isn't released locally or only gets released months or years after release overseas. I'm quite happy to pay for the discs I want and to purchase them legally, but I'm annoyed when zoning means that I simply can't get and play a disc I want without also having to buy a second player from overseas in order to play it, and then also have to deal with any problems related to differences in our electricity supplies.
David Aiken
The link below will take you to the Blu-raystats.com site. Just change the audio to DTS-MA or DTS-HD and click "filter" on the right. Not all discs list the number of channels, but many of them do.
These discs are probably Region A, so the actual stats may be different for other regions depending on the distributor. For instance, the T3 encoding for the US DVD is Dolby Digital, while the UK version of T3 on DVD has a DTS soundtrack. Warner Bros in the US always dicks us with no DTS, but WB has always stood for crap audio. Even their Dolby TrueHD encodes use the default Dialog Normalization "ON" setting for Blu-ray.
Just checked the 6.1 list. Apart from X-Men 3, the only one I have is Reservoir Dogs which is listed as a Lionsgate release. My copy is from Lionsgate but the packaging just says DTS HD 5.1. The PS3 says DTS HD HR 6.1 so I do have a second 6.1 disc.
David Aiken
Post a Followup:
| FAQ |
Post a Message! |
Forgot Password? |
|
||||||||||||||
|
||||||||||||||
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Top of Page ]
[ Contact Us ]
[ Support/Wish List ]
[ Copyright © 2025, Audio Asylum, all rights reserved ]
